A healthy summer dessert with a maple banana sweetened sunbutter ice cream filling that everyone will love. This ice cream pie is also paleo, vegan, refined sugar free and no bake!
It’s probably not a secret that I’m trying to up my game with my recipe photos lately. Or is it, because now I’m feeling like they still really suck and you were not assuming I was trying hard. I have issues with “letting people see me sweat.” Figuratively I mean, because literally I sweat all the time.

Slowly, one by one, I will make my old recipes and re-photograph them, I think. Has anyone done this? I started with my basic egg scramble and sweet potato hash because the photos made me gag and I make these things all the time anyway. Some of the others might be tougher, like my chipotle chicken salad or chicken with pesto. These take longer to make, plus I still don’t know if I’d be able to take good pictures. I am just so daredevil lately. Or tired, let’s go with tired.
I’ve only been really getting into sunflower butter recently, but now I’m just a little hooked on adding it to recipes in place of nut butter if I’m not feeling all that nutty or coconutty. Honestly I think my family is sick of coconut and I might have had enough of it too, at least for a little while.
As for the crust, it’s nearly the same as the crust I created for my pumpkin pie last September, except this one isn’t baked. Turns out it really doesn’t need to be, unless you prefer a little toastiness to your crust. Feel free to bake for 10-15 minutes at 350 before cooling and adding the filling!
Banana Sunbutter Ice Cream Pie

Ingredients
- For the Crust:
- 3/4 cup walnuts or pecans
- 3/4 cup nut meal/flour of choice I used hazelnut meal
- 2.5 tbsp coconut oil at room temp
- 1/4 cup raisins you can omit to make this low FODMAP
- 1 tsp organic coconut sugar add 1 tbsp if omitting the raisins for low FODMAP
- 1 tsp cinnamon
- For the Filling:
- 1 med-large ripe banana
- 2/3 cup sunflower seed butter
- 1/3 cup unsweetened almond milk or other non dairy milk
- 2 tsp pure maple syrup
- 1 tsp vanilla
Instructions
-
For the crust, combine all crust ingredients in a food processor and blend until it forms a paste.
-
Press crust evenly into a nonstick 9 inch pie plate (or line a pie plate with parchment paper for easy removal)
-
Set crust aside, covered, in the freezer while you make the filling.
-
For the filling, combine all filling ingredients in a blender until creamy and pour into pie crust, scraping sides with a rubber spatula to get every drop in there!
-
Cover pie with plastic wrap and freeze for at least 2 hours or until firm. Before serving, let it thaw enough to cut into slices.
-
Enjoy!

What’s your favorite summer dessert?
What are you most excited for this weekend?









I LOVE this so much! Sun butter cream pie literally sounds like heaven to me! I would love to try to make this, and please- your photography skills totally kill ;).
Thanks so much, you are too kind!!
This looks great! I love sunbutter. I have debated doing something similar with my old recipes. The pictures are so terrible it’s embarassing!
Yeah I just didn’t consider photography at all since it wasn’t a strength of mine or on my radar. Big mistake!
Yummmyyy! You combined two of my favorite things – bananas and nut butter. Especially sun butter.
Hope you try it out! Two of my favorites as well 🙂
YUM! This sounds so delicious! Alex and I have been trying to do a “no added sugar thing” and this pretty much fits the bill!
Hope it doesn’t disappoint! You can try adding a bit more banana to sweeten it up if maple is out.
Your photos are for sure getting better (and that’s not saying they were bad before!) I love sunbutter and I’ve never ad a dessert with it in it before outside of paleo reese’s eggs at Easter. This pie looks awesome!
Hmm, some were pretty bad, but thank you!! Now I want paleo reese’s eggs, somehow missed that one!
Just found your blog and I absolutely love it! So excited to try this recipe with peanut or almond butter. It looks scrumptious and I love the crust ingredients 🙂
I’m sure it would be delicious no matter what nut butter you use! Glad you found me, thanks 🙂