This super easy, 4 ingredient paleo and vegan chocolate pudding is so rich, creamy, and chocolatey that you won’t believe it’s dairy free, healthy, and refined sugar free! Top with coconut whipped cream for a perfectly dreamy chocolate dessert.
Do you happen to remember my rant/warning about making coconut whipped cream with the right kind of canned coconut cream/milk? About the sad, sad times I spent trying to save whipped cream that didn’t whip at all, but rather turned into something that resembled cottage cheese?
I’ll say it has happened enough times to me over the course of the past two months for me to finally just stick to using canned coconut cream rather than the separated milk at all.
However, my whipped cream tragedy did have a light at the end of the tunnel, a bright side, a victory! You know how they say when life hands you lemons, make lemonade? I say when life hands you un-whippable coconut cream, make chocolate pudding!
I’m talking ridiculously easy, so easy that it’s even possible to make it when the last thing you want to do in the world is cook ANYTHING.
The truth is, I “discovered” this recipe long ago in a desperate attempt to not waste a $2.50 can of coconut milk after it failed at whipping properly. After making it about 3 times after the same problem occurred, I realized it was becoming one of my favorite desserts, and it was time to make things official 🙂
I like the irony of my photos (not 100% sure this is actually irony) with the perfectly whipped coconut cream sitting on top of pudding that was born from coconut cream that wouldn’t whip.
If you haven’t read the other post and want to make deliciously creamy coconut whipped cream to top your pudding, I recommend you use this brand of canned cream (they’re small cans of cream only) which hasn’t failed me yet.
Since this recipe is pleasantly easy, I barely have any real tips before sending you along on your way to chocolate bliss! I would say first, make sure you sift your cacao (or cocoa) to make it easy to achieve a nice smooth and creamy pudding when you whisk everything.
I also found it effective to use a small whisk to get around the edges of the saucepan as well. But remember, if all else fails, just break out your immersion blender at the end, which has saved me during those times I forgot was too lazy to sift the cacao.
I hope you’re ready for rich creamy chocolate heaven in a bowl! Let’s make this pudding!
Easy Paleo & Vegan Chocolate Pudding {Dairy-Free}
Easy Paleo & Vegan Chocolate Pudding {Dairy-Free}
Ingredients
- 1 1/2 cups organic coconut cream from a can*
- 1/2 cup raw cacao powder or unsweetened cocoa powder, sifted
- 6 Tbsp pure maple syrup 6-8 Tbsp depending on how sweet you want it
- 2 tsp pure vanilla extract
- generous pinch fine grain sea salt
Instructions
- In a small saucepan over low heat, whisk together the coconut cream, cacao, and maple syrup (start with 6 Tbsp, or even less if you want a very dark chocolate pudding) until smooth. I used a small whisk to get everything nice and smooth.
- The coconut cream will melt and the maple and cacao should combine well to create a smooth silky mixture. Continue to cook and stir over low/med heat for about 2 minutes, or until the mixture just begins to come to a boil with small bubbles.
- Remove from heat at this point, and stir in the salt and vanilla. Taste, and add a bit more maple if you'd like a sweeter pudding. You can pour the mixture into individual containers/bowls to chill and set, or simply in one larger bowl only and divide later on.
- Cover and refrigerate until set, or overnight for a thick creamy pudding. Makes about 4 servings. I love my pudding with a big dollop of coconut whipped cream on top! Enjoy!
Recipe Notes
*You can use this canned coconut cream, or you can use the thick part of a chilled, separated can of coconut milk. For this particular recipe, I used the Thai Kitchen full fat canned coconut milk, just the cream part.
Nutrition
What I Used To Make My Paleo & Vegan Chocolate Pudding:
Want more paleo and vegan chocolate desserts? Try one of these!
Soft Chocolate Chip Cookies {Paleo & Vegan}
Almond Butter Fudge Chunk “Nice Cream”
Chocolate Chip Cookie Vanilla Cheesecake
Tell Me!
What was you most awesome cooking/recipe “save”?
Note: This post contains Amazon affiliate links. This means that if you click on a link and make a purchase, I will receive a small commission at no cost to you. Thank you for supporting Paleo Running Momma!
My little angels will love this, you are awesome, this is super simple!
Great! Hope you like it 🙂
I made a half batch tonight and didn’t realize until this very moment that I forgot to halve the cocoa. The whole time, I was thinking, “Wow! I must have a HUGE sweet tooth!” because I had to double (or something like that – I just kept adding more and more 😀 ) the maple and coconut cream. Haha. But once I did that, it was delicious! Even my husband who doesn’t like healthy cocoa based puddings loved it!
Thanks for the awesome recipe! I’ll try to make it correctly next time. 🙂
Lol, I’ve done things like that 🙂 So glad it worked out anyway this time, luckily it’s pretty resilient!
Is the syrup for sweetening and texture? Do you think using a sweetener such as Swerve or Sukrin Gold would work with this in place of the syrup, for those of us who are wanting a lower carb option?
You can use any other liquid sweetener and it wouldn’t affect the texture. I wouldn’t go with granulated though since it won’t dissolve well enough.
Fantastic your amazing!
I bought the can of coconut cream you recommended, but there is still some coconut water in the bottom of the jar. Do you use this or save for another purpose?
My kids loved this. I loved that I could give them a treat that’s good for them. Thanks!
Trader Joe’s carries coconut cream in the can (its in a red can). Works really well for whipped toppings without the fuss of skimming the cream from the milk. Another tip is to keep everything cold- freeze or refrigerate your mixing bowl and whisk prior to making your whipped topping.
Can you make vanilla pudding using the same recipe minus the cocoa powder? I would love to make a Banana pudding but can’t find a recipe for vanilla pudding for vegan/gluten free/ paleo! Any suggestions
I’m not sure how that would turn out, but I do think it would be delicious even if it didn’t taste exactly like vanilla pudding 🙂
yes its right
Can you make this a couple of days ahead of time?
Yes definitely!
This looks delicious! I have been looking for a recipe that doesn’t have avacado in it! Haha
I made this and the next day it was more like frosting or fudge than pudding. any suggestions?
The coconut cream makes it firm up when chilled, at room temp it’s more pudding like, if that makes sense 🙂 You can also just use full fat coconut milk so it doesn’t firm up as much.
I followed the recipe and it only firmed up on top, the rest was still super liquidy after chilling almost 24 hours. What did I do wrong? I used a can of coconut cream and followed the recipe exactly! (It tastes delicious, but it’s soup)
Strange, I have no idea what happened! If anything it’s usually very thick after being chilled, I’m guessing the coconut cream separated somehow, perhaps the brand had something added to it that caused this? Wish I knew so I could help!
Maybe it’s because I used the liquidy part of the coconut cream as well as the thick part! That’s all I can think of! Well, it’s so tasty so I’ll definitely try it again! Thanks!!
Your presentation is amazing! I just had to make these and I have to say that this became my kid’s favorite. Thank you Michele for sharing this tasty and easy recipe.
Happy you liked it 🙂
It’s been 48 hours in the fridge and it’s still liquidy like water 🙁
Was I supposed to use a mixer or anything to “fluff” it up?
No…did you use coconut cream from a can? It’s so thick that if anything, the pudding is thicker than a regular pudding. If you used a thin dairy free milk that’s mostly water, that would explain the liquid factor, otherwise I can’t think of anything. Sorry it didn’t work out!
Mine was very liquidy as well. Like a hot fudge. Can’t really eat it that way. Wish it was fluffy like it shows in the picture. seems like I need to add some whipped coconut cream or something
Did you use coconut cream (not a thinner milk) and cooled the mixture before serving? I don’t see how it could turn out liquidy if you use thick canned coconut cream, which is very firm when chilled.
Hello 🙂
This looks delicious !
Can I use raw stevia powder instead of the maple syrup ? And if so how much ?
I haven’t ever used that so I’m not sure how it would work.
Can I substitute something in place of thecoconut cream? My fiancé just found out he needs to be on a dairy free diet but hates anything that tastes like coconut :/
I’m not sure what you could sub in there to mimic the texture and keep it paleo/vegan. Sorry!
So, Good!!! I did have to add a lot more maple syrup. My kiddos are going to love this treat.
Glad you enjoyed!
HI!
Do you think I could freeze this into pops, or would it be too icy?
thanks!
I haven’t tried it but I do have a no churn chocolate ice cream recipe that’s similar but may work better:
Do you think this would work with soya cream?
Thank you for the recipe!
Emilie
I’m sorry but not sure, I’ve only tested it with thick coconut cream.
I added 2 Tblsp of organic pumpkin puree while i heated the coconut cream. Amazing rich flavor!
Sounds great – glad you liked it!
What is a serving size? As I am trying to figure out calories per serving.
hey so this recipe says it only take 7 minutes total? would be good to have the time to set included as this was a bit misleading. thanks.
These turned out beautifully! SOOO DELICIOUS! And so easy to make.
Thanks!
So glad you enjoyed!
Made this for my kids and I couldn’t stop eating it myself! Very simple yet delicious.
I’ve made this recipe twice, and expect to make it many more times. The second time I made it I put all the ingredients in my Vitamix, wet ingredients first. It turned out lighter and fluffier than the stovetop method and it set in the refrigerator faster, which was good because I didn’t want to wait to eat it!
That sounds great, I’ll have to try it!
what setting did you use on your Vitamix and for how long did you blend it?
Love it!
Be sure the coconut cream you use doesn’t contain guar gum
Thank you for sharing. Was looking online to see if canned coconut milk can be used for pudding and found your site. Your recipes all look delicious and I will be back. For the chocolate pudding, I have coconut milk, not cream, so I was thinking of thickening with cornstarch as I normally would for pudding recipes. What did you do with the liquid from the can you didn’t use for pudding? Also, half cup cocoa seems like so much, but your results look great! I want to try thisrecipe. Then I will come back! Thanks again!
Hi there! I made this with a can of coconut cream but used the entire can including the thick liquid. It tastes amazing but didn’t set properly. Any suggestions on what I can use this chocolate liquid for?
Just made this recipe for the first time tonight (as directed aside from adding 2 squares of Ghirardelli 92% cacao chocolate to richen it up further), and the pudding is chilling in the fridge currently. However, with 1/4th of the mixture I decided (instead of putting it in a ramekin like the rest) that I’d pour it into a mug and top it off with almond milk (vanilla unsweetened). Basically a dairy-free hot chocolate drink. So delicious! Looking forward to having the pudding for dessert with my guy tomorrow. Thanks for the recipe! 🙂
Following up the next day, my pudding wasn’t setting last night so I added a little bit of chia seeds and xanthum gum to see if that would do the trick. Worked like a charm. 🙂 Enjoying creamy, thick pudding as I type this.
This looks so rich and chocolatey! I need this in my life right now! Yum!!
This pudding is amazing. I admit, I was skeptical at first, but I saw all the other rave reviews and thought I had to try it; especially since it was so simple to make. My mind has been blown since making this. My toddler loves it too! He kept calling it chocolate ice cream bc that’s his favorite and I was so happy I was able to let him indulge in something that was free from all that junk in normal treats. Thank you, thank you, thank you for this recipe!! It’s a winner. Note: I only got one can of coconut cream (5.4 oz) and realized upon opening that was not going to equal to 1.5 cups. So I basically halved the recipe and it turned out with the perfect consistency…maybe a little more chocolately than i expected, so next time I will get more cans so that I can make the full amount. It might be okay to note that in the recipe as well for others.
This looks so rich and chocolatey! I need this in my life right now! Yum!!
try it you want moreee
For the chocolate pudding recipe can you use raw honey instead of maple syrup?
Hi Michele! Love your recipes!! When I’m looking for something specific, you are one of the bloggers I start with! I just want to say though that Thai Kitchen coconut milk has guar gum, which should be avoided. AroyD makes one without it. It came in second place on America’s Test Kitchen so I think it’s superior without the additives. Just thought your readers should know that. Thanks for all you do!!!
Have you ever tried Trader Joe’s Coconut Cream? I just used it for the first time in a Curry Chicken soup and a portion of the Can was solid and the rest liquid.
For this recipe should I put the coconut cream in the fridge? I’m curious if the one you recommended is always solid? I’ve never tried it before either.
Delicious
Everytime i try to make a pudding like this it is still liquid form after being in the fridge for a long tine. I used the same exact ingredients and measurements. I’m not sure what I did wrong.
Thanks for sharing this recipe, i will try to make this cake.
To buy, put coconut cream in a box (in a red box). It helps to shake off the filling without affecting the cream cream. Another recommendation is to place everything in a cool place or wash the dishes and heat before shaking.
Paleo and Vegan Chocolate Pudding {Nut Free}
i love this article!!
chocolate pudding
Can you use the pudding and add to a nut crust for chocolate pudding pie? My family does this with regular pudding and looking for a paleo friendly option!
Thanks
I use this to make a pie for thanks giving. It was heavenly. My husband loved it.
its so good i love it thanks for sharing
i will give it 5 star , coz its really faboulous
So easy & it came out great! Thank you <3
I’ve tried making this recipe a few times, and it has not worked out. It always ends up remaining liquidy. I’m new to this paleo world, and I feel like it’s me making the mistake. What is the difference between milk and cream? Am I supposed to scoop out the white stuff in the can, and not just dump the whole thing into a pan with the water? Should I drain the white stuff first? Am I not cooling it down long enough?
Yes that’s right, scoop out the hardened cream at the top of the can. I haven’t tried using the whole can (cream and milk) but I think it would turn out runny, like you’re describing. Also make sure to use full fat coconut milk. Otherwise, I don’t think you’ll get that cream at the top. Good luck!
I have been following you for years. Your recipes are amazing. Have used most of them. Keep up the good job.
Amazing!!!!
Couldn’t get the coconut whip cream to work but absolutely delicious by itself.
?????
Thank you for the recipe!
This recipe turned out PERFECTLY!! I used 4 Tbsp of maple syrup and it was the perfect amount of sweet for me. I’ve had so much trouble trying to make that coconut milk whipped cream too! But now I’m not worried about trying it again because I have this amazing pudding to fall back on lol. Thank you!
The first time I made it, I used 6 Tbsp of maple syrup and it was still too sweet for my taste. So for people who rarely consume suger, I’d suggest 4 Tbsp.
Decadent! Has a mousse-like texture when coming out of the fridge, which is exactly what I was looking for (: and super simple to make!
I used coconut cream from a chilled can of coconut milk and ended up with less than a cup’s worth of cream, so I had to reduce the other ingredients accordingly. It was a too sweet for my liking so I will further reduce the sugar content next time (I used the 6 TBS equivalent) like some of the previous commenters said.
Mine turned out SUPER runny. I don’t know what happened. I even let it sit for 4+ hours in the fridge.
I followed the recipe, poured the pudding in individual containers then drilled past the ad where I saw ‘recipe notes’ and read that just the cream part of the coconut milk was used. My pudding, after 8 hours in the frig is runny . I would have benefited from this note being in the body of the recipe. I’ll use just the dense cream next time.
Looks good! Do you think if I froze this, it would turn out like froyo?
I froze mine to get it to set quickly and after an hour had part pudding, part ice cream. Incredibly delicious!
Hello!
I followed the recipe and it has been refrigerated for about 4 hours. But it looks like it’s separated… coconut is sitting on top. Did I do something wrong?
This pudding tastes so much like your typical box mix, but without as much guilt. It’s delicious! Definitely go all out and do the whip cream too. My kids, 5 & 2 were so excited to have this for dessert. My 5 year old keeps taking about Paleo Running Momma too. We also liked the banana almond butter bars.
This looks delicious! I am staying away from pretty much all sugar so could I sub Stevia for the maple syrup? If so, how much do you think? I can’t wait to try this!
A nice recipe like to try it thanks for sharing
After reading the reviews I decided to add 1 tsp of corn starch while stirring over the stove to make sure it was reasonably thickened. I also added perhaps a just little extra cocoa. I poured the mixture into a cooked pie shell and chilled in the fridge. The result was a truly decadent bittersweet chocolate pudding pie that sliced smoothly like chilled butter. I used the Trader Joe’s coconut cream from a can (the entire can), and I am guessing the tsp of corn starch was likely entirely unnecessary, but it was delicious regardless.
Your put on the very bottom to use only the solid part in the canned coconut, it would have been nice to see that above, I made it already, with the whole can as it did not specify in the directions but in a fine line,way at the bottom i discovered after the fact,,, ,, so disappointed
I rarely leave reviews, but this was INCREDIBLE. I’m at the tail end of an elimination diet, and I’ve got a dairy sensitivity. A lot of recipes I’ve tried during this time to make accommodations for the diet have just been “eh”. But I just got such an intense craving for chocolate pudding tonight that I had to do something, and this was the first search result!!
I used Arroy-D coconut cream in a carton – I don’t have much experience with coconut cream, so I was nervous about not using a can, but it worked perfectly. There was so much cream in the carton that I didn’t really have to worry about refrigerating it for separation.
I also used dark cocoa powder, and needed 7 tablespoons of maple syrup for it to get sweet enough.
Lastly, I put it in the freezer to set quickly, and in an hour part of it froze into a delicious ice cream consistency. I’m also pretty sure I’ll be able to modify this recipe to make chocolate mousse, my all time favorite, without the dairy kicking my butt.
All that to say, this will be a recipe I make again and again – thank you so so much!
Outstanding!
Easy and fantastic!
So this was really good. Rich, creamy and oh so chocolately! My husband loved it. I made parfaits and layered it with crushed gluten free graham crackers and whipped cream (holiday splurge) in small jelly jars. I was worried about it setting up because it seemed so thin but after about 4-5 hours in the fridge it got thick enough to call pudding. I used only the thick solid cream part of my cold can of coconut milk – I actually had to strain it because it didn’t chill into one solid mass. I only used 5 Tbsp of maple syrup, not quite all of the cocoa powder either (about 1 Tbsp or so less) and the flavor was perfect – very chocolately and just barely sweet enough. Will definitely make this again. thank you!